Bellevue Christian Counseling Logo

  • ServicesRead about the expertise available
    • Individual ServicesAddress your personal concerns confidentially
      • ADHD
      • Abandonment Issues and Neglect
      • Aging and Geriatric Issues
      • Anger Management
      • Anxiety
      • Autism Spectrum Disorder
      • Bipolar Disorder
      • Chemical Dependency
      • Counseling for Children
      • Counseling for Teens
      • Codependency
      • Depression
      • Eating Disorders
      • EMDR
      • Grief and loss Counseling
      • Individual Counseling
      • Infidelity and Affairs
      • Lifespan Integration Therapy
      • Men’s Issues
      • OCD
      • Personal Development
      • Psychological Testing
      • PTSD
      • Relationship Issues
      • Sex And Porn Addiction
      • Sexual Abuse
      • Spiritual Development
      • Trauma
      • Weight Loss
      • Women’s Issues
    • Christian Couples CounselingWork through challenges together
      • Couples Counseling
      • Premarital Counseling
      • Marriage Counseling
    • Family CounselingEstablish the peaceful home you desire
      • Christian Counseling for Children
        and Teens
      • Family Counseling
    • Group CounselingBenefit from the support of others
      • Men’s Sexual Addiction Recovery
        Group
      • All Counseling Groups
    • Online Counseling
    • Anxiety
    • Depression
    • Marriage Counseling
    • Sex And Porn Addiction
  • LocationsChoose from our variety of office locations
    • Bellevue Office FrontBellevue
    • Bothell Office Front EntranceBothell
    • Edmonds Christian CounselingEdmonds
    • Everett Office Front EntranceEverett
    • Federal Way Office FrontFederal Way
    • Hansville
    • Kent 2Kent
    • Kirkland Christian CounselingKirkland
    • LaceyLacey
    • Mill Creek Office Waiting RoomMill Creek
    • Monroe
    • Oak Harbor Office OutsideOak Harbor
    • Poulsbo
    • Puyallup Christian CounselingPuyallup
    • Redmond OfficeRedmond
    • Seattle Downtown OfficeSeattle Downtown
    • Seattle Greenlake 2Seattle Greenlake
    • Silverdale Office FrontSilverdale
    • Tacoma Office FrontTacoma
    • Spokane ValleySpokane Valley
    • Vancouver
    •  1Online Counseling
  • CounselorsFind the best counselor for your needs
  • CareersBecome an affiliated Christian counselor
  • (425) 939-6856Please give us a call, we are here to help
header-image

Renewing the Tension In Your Marriage is Not a Problem but a Solution

Bellevue Christian Counseling
https://bellevuechristiancounseling.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/renewing-the-tension-in-your-marriage-is-not-a-problem-but-a-solution-2.jpg 199 300
https://bellevuechristiancounseling.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/bellevue.jpg
https://bellevuechristiancounseling.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/cropped-cropped-seattle-logo.png
330 112th Ave NE, Suite 302
BELLEVUE, WA 98004
United States
330 112th Ave NE, Suite 302
BELLEVUE, WA 98004
United States
Photo of Barney Armstrong

Barney Armstrong

Jan
2013
10

Renewing the Tension In Your Marriage is Not a Problem but a Solution

Barney Armstrong

Marriage Counseling

By Barney Armstrong, MA, LMHCA, Bellevue Christian Counseling

Autonomy and Dependence: The Dialectic of Marriage

You definitely need more tension! In your marriage that is.

Marriage is brilliantly designed; it has a built-in dialectic of dependence and autonomy that demands that you continually be alive to your marriage – it won’t let you live by formulas or the boredom that you naturally tend toward.

What is a dialectic? A dialectic is not a paradox – it doesn’t say two things that can’t both be true – no, it instructs you by holding two things in tension. The Bible, for example, is often dialectic. It keeps us from living on autopilot and requires that we be alive to Scripture.

Like us if you are enjoying this content.

For example: The Bible tells us not to lay up treasures on earth (Mt 6:19) and to love not the world nor the things in the world (I J 2:15). On the other hand it tells us that it is wise to store up food in the summer (Prov. 6:8; 10:5), and we are told that God richly supplies us with all things to enjoy

(I Tim. 6:17). If you want to live by formulas and only consider the first set, you might give everything away, never work or provide resources for your family, and maybe start a cult around your extremism. If you only consider the second set you might be a miser and a hedonist. The two sets of ideas are not in conflict, they create a tension that refuses to let you diminish the Bible to formulas and requires you to be alive to the Scripture.

Amazingly, the dialectical nature of marriage will not allow you to go on autopilot; you must be alive to your marriage. It doesn’t reduce to formulas. Marriage requires you to be dependent on your mate, to be fully trusting and vulnerable to your spouse. Surprisingly, for such things to be meaningful, they must be the choices of someone who is first fully autonomous. Not a paradox! How meaningful is trust, vulnerability and dependence if it’s not a real choice, if you have to, if it’s by default or passive?

We tend to fall into exactly that — it’s the kind of dependence we had as a child. We were dependent on parents, trusting and vulnerable. And they could be anywhere from totally loving to horribly abusive, but we had no choice, it was by default –our “choice” carried no meaning with it, it was passive. In marriage we tend to want things to settle down and be predictable; we would like benefits that require nothing of us, like when we were kids. We reduce our mate to a box … dependable but boring — and our “choice” becomes passive – not romantic like it used to be (remember when you were dating? This completely other person was choosing you!)

So this is definitely the wrong model for marriage! Yet we tend toward it because it’s the model we are used to and it requires no effort. In a marriage we must be adults and autonomous peers who are continually choosing each other wittingly. Otherwise our choices carry no meaning – they are not romantic, and marriage is boring.

The other extreme is being only autonomous, independent without the purpose of choosing your mate – manifested in things like spending all of your time out “with the boys,” or texting your girlfriends the whole time he’s driving — avoiding your mate wherever possible.

A couple I was recently talking with saw their romantic attachment to each other dramatically bubble to the surface on the eve of his leaving on an extended business trip—his departure made their independence tangible, and so their attachment became vivid as well. Autonomy and dependence, self-motivation and deference, independence and commitment, self-reliance and trust – all are pairs of ideas that when each held in one hand, create a tension, a posture toward your everyday interaction that demands you to grow in your own personhood and be alive to your mate and your marriage.

Sitting with a Christian marriage counselor can help you renew this healthy tension in your marriage! That is — to help you see where you are being passive, where you need to grow in autonomy, and where you need to grow in vulnerability with your mate.

 

Images cc: freedigitalphotos.com – Lovers in the Farm and Green apple vs. red apple both photostock

DISCLAIMER: THIS ARTICLE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE

The information, including but not limited to, text, graphics, images and other material contained on this article are for informational purposes only. No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Please contact one of our counselors for further information.

  • Share on Facebook
  • Tweet it
  • ↑ Back to top
Photo of Barney Armstrong
Barney is currently not accepting new clients

Barney Armstrong

Licensed Counselor
(206) 701-9144 barneya@bellevuechristiancounseling.com

Life should be more than just pain and trials. Though they can serve a purpose, I believe that God has much more in store for you. My hope is to help you discover the wonderful joys and strength that lie beneath the pain and trauma you might be facing. Through Christ, we can conquer fear and find freedom, healing, and purpose. Whatever challenges you face, I offer you a safe place for you to discover all that God can do for your life. Read more articles by Barney »

Other articles that might interest you...

People, Not Marriage, Cause Marriage Problems
Photo of Benjamin Deu

Benjamin Deu

People, Not Marriage, Cause Marriage ...

Written by Benjamin Deu, MA, LMHC, Seattle Christian Counseling References “Intimacy & Desire” by Dr. David Schnarch  ‘Relationship ecology’ Think...

continue reading »
spacer
Photo of Barney Armstrong

Barney Armstrong

Sexual Boredom in an ...

When a couple is committed to one another in a caring relationship, there is a natural progression in their physical...

continue reading »
spacer

About Barney

Photo of Barney Armstrong

Barney Armstrong, MA, LMHC

Licensed Counselor

Life should be more than just pain and trials. Though they can serve a purpose, I believe that God has much more in store for you. My hope is to help you discover the wonderful joys and strength that lie beneath the pain and trauma you might be facing. Through Christ, we can conquer fear and find freedom, healing, and purpose. Whatever challenges you face, I offer you a safe place for you to discover all that God can do for your life. View Barney's Profile

Recent articles by Barney

  • Aug 13 · How to Cure Depression: Is it Really Possible?
  • Mar 23 · Codependency Recovery: Two Expert Tips
  • Jun 26 · How to Forgive and Really Mean It: Part II
See all articles by Barney »

Related Services

  • Marriage Counseling

Barney's Office Locations

  • Photo of the Bellevue office

    Bellevue

    Washington

    General Office Number

    (425) 939-6856
    330 112th Ave NE,, Suite 302 Bellevue, WA 98004

    View Office Details
  • Photo of the Redmond office

    Redmond

    Washington

    General Office Number

    (425) 250-6282
    8195 166th Avenue Northeast, suite 204 Redmond, WA 98052

    View Office Details
  • Photo of the Online (WA only) office

    Online (WA only)

    General Office Number

    (206) 388-3929
    ,  

    View Office Details
Bellevue Christian Counseling Logo
Bellevue Christian Counseling
Professional help with faith-based values
We are an association of professional, independently licensed Christian counselors experienced in helping people of all ages find healing for a wide variety of issues.
© 2025 Bellevue Christian Counseling. All rights reserved.
330 112th Ave NE,, Bellevue, WA 98004. Tel (425) 939-6856.
Facebook Twitter Online Counseling About Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use Feel free to contact us!
We are open for business. In person and online counseling are available now.